Essay Title: 


March 23, 2016 | Author: | Posted in art, movies


Journal Response

Scott Hayder ‘s Poltergeist : It Knows What Scares You

FirstName LastName

Association /School

Journal Response

Scott Hayder ‘s Poltergeist : It Knows What Scares You

Scott Hyder ‘s article Poltergeist : It Knows What Scares You ‘ is an homage to Steven Speilberg ‘s movie Poltergeist , but amidst Hyder ‘s gushing , he also turns a critical eye toward the subtle but important difference between quality horror movies , fright movies , and suspense movies

Although Hyder admits that a mere synopsis simply cannot give a real [banner_entry_middle]

feel for [Poltergeist ‘s story] ‘ he does begin with some plot detail before moving into a thoughtful discussion of the importance of both character and score to the film ‘s supremacy (Hyder

He concludes that a horror movie [ .] cannot rely on terror , anger and disbelief to hold its audience for two hours ‘ and goes on to generalize that if a horror movie has [like Poltergeist] a well-developed plot with superior actors and an excellent score to accompany their emotions , then it should be a sure winner at the box office (Hyder

Hyder compares Poltergeist with Rosemary ‘s Baby , The Exorcist , and the original Psycho in fact , he not only compares them , but he claims that Poltergeist ‘s special effects place it in class of its own

Having classified movies such as The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and A Nightmare on Elm Street as more fright-based (i .e . less satisfying and less successful , he concludes by saying that unlike movies like Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom , the believability of what occurred in Poltergeist makes it superior in terms of audience satisfaction and box office success . This , according to Hyder , places Spielberg ‘s movie into the special area of Horror known as Suspense

I found Scott Hyder ‘s piece interesting however , there were parts I disagreed with . First , his comparison of Poltergeist with Rosemary ‘s Baby , The Exorcist , and the original Psycho seemed ill-founded , and in part contrary to his hypothesis . Both Rosemary ‘s Baby and The Exorcist are extremely violent , gory , frightening movies , and most of their characters are one-dimensional and do not beg an audience for sympathy The original Psycho , like Hitchcock ‘s The Birds broke new ground in storyline , character development , and acting , and even implying Poltergeist has a similarity with , let alone a superiority to either of these is simply poor analysis – it reeks of Hyder ‘s favorable prejudice towards Spielberg ‘s film

The other area that stood out to me as not well thought-out occured when Hyder discussed believability and mentions John Carpenter ‘s The Thing and David Croneberg ‘s Scanners as movies doomed to lesser success than Poltergeist (or similar films his explanation is that neither fits the realm of possibility , but I think that is of less relevance than timing no matter how good a film is in any or every area , if the viewing audience isn ‘t ready for it (for whatever reason , it will not be remembered as good ‘ and it not will… [banner_entry_footer]

Comments Off on journal


This author has published 9190 articles so far. More info about the author is coming soon.

Comments are closed.